Years ago a visit to Hamburg, Germany coincided with the city’s 750th birthday celebration which culminated in a huge fireworks display in the harbor. As the sun lowered we made our way through oldtown to secure a good viewing site. My host family walked me through the the most sinful mile, the historic Reeperbahn District, (ropemaker’s district,) which has been and still is a famous stopover for seamen and others seeking sins of the night.
The fireworks were amazing, as was the crowd. I didn’t know it was possible to sardine-pack so many strangers in such a confined space. As the spectacular show was drawing to a close, the crowd began to shift and my feet left the ground. My host mother, sensing what was about to transpire, clutched my arm in her right hand and her daughter’s arm in her left hand and began plowing through the mass of people like an ox dragging a Conestoga wagon over Donner Pass. We stumbled through vendor booths and past noisy, red-light doorways. I’ve never forgotten the terror of fighting through that crowd or the stony determination of dear Christine to rescue her chicks from very possible destruction.
The memory of that exhausting night caused me to chuckle when I arrived in downtown Butte, Montana on a sightseeing adventure for which our primary goal was to find the infamous Dumas Brothel. The Dumas is the last remaining monument of the many brothels that vied for miners’ paychecks during the early nineteenth century. It was the longest running active brothel in U.S. history, operating from 1890 until 1982.
Butte, however, is the antithesis of Hamburg. Once a bustling den of inequity and rich copper barons, Butte has been slowly deteriorating since mining has decreased. With a placemat-sized map of tourist attractions, we wandered about on a quiet Sunday admiring what was left of the town’s rich history. There are the copper king mansions, some of which have been beautifully restored into new uses as B&Bs. There’s a mineral museum and a mining museum, a Chinese cultural museum, a church on practically every corner, and a lot of down-in-the-heels old mansions and business buildings that appear to have been snapped up by wealthy outside investors and which hunker in various stages of renovation. I believe this town is in the process of a makeover.
We drove a circuitous route through dirt poor housing to find the Granite Mountain Mine Memorial, a tribute to the men lost in the Granite Mountain-Speculator Fire of 1917, as well as to other Butte men lost in the course of mining Butte’s copper deposits. An interactive panel plays audio clips about the fire and community. Plaques list the the names of men lost in the Granite Mountain-Speculator Fire as well as commemorate the experiences and heroism of those involved.
But all along, what we really wanted to find was that darned brothel. It was a lot harder to find than Hamburg’s Reeparbahn! Turns out the entrance to the brothel was off an alley skirted by a parking lot and a park of sorts. During the tourist season it is possible to schedule a tour of the interior, however during the winter the only action was a filming company that was using the interior for a shoot.

Aha! There it is, with a crusty customer waiting in line….socially distanced.

Street murals to spice up the park(ing lot).

I’m sure there’s action to be had somewhere in Butte these days, but unlike Hamburg, the sex industry now operates underground, no pun intended.
Without being one of the working women, I am curious what the interior would look like. Hopefully better than the exterior!
LikeLike
I suspect the interior would have looked even worse, upon close inspection. Yikes. I’m sure it was pretty dark inside, precluding much close inspection. 🧐
LikeLiked by 1 person
How sweet!!! My momma taking action, nice to have a memory of her strong and capable instead of weak and confused… thank you! Love Ursula
LikeLike
Oh Yeah, your momma was a momma bear, for sure! I will never forget how fierce she was and how shocked I was that she just plunged right through some of the vendor’s stalls to get her charges out of there!
LikeLike
Some of your details about Butte remind me of Virginia City NV and its silver lining history. Butte’s restoration initiative sounds like a winner. Thanks for your Idaho travelogues and photos….an invaluable book in the making.
LikeLike
Thanks, Karen. Butte surely has a lot in common with VC. However, I think it was an active mining town much more recently, actually, I think there’s still some mining going on around there. Just not as much. And it is not yet as touristy as VC. That may well change soon.
LikeLike
I don’t know why, but I’ve always liked the sound of “Butte.” Butte, Montana resonates in my head similarly to the sound of Smackover, Arkansas. Kind of makes me think a circle of drinks had a town-naming meeting and they went with first choice in these cases, as with countless others.
LikeLike
Smackover!? Holy cow. That’s really funny. I guess I don’t think too much about the name Butte, because, as a geographic feature, we’ve got buttes all over the west. But I love your vision of a circle of drinks at the town naming meeting!
LikeLike
I was immediately reminded of the jokes about 1st. Street in Laramie…
I drove down it…one block of tiny shacks. Brothels were always there, in the shadows. I stayed in a renovated brothel in New Orleans…a charming place in the French Quarter. The bar was still all red velvet and mirrors.
There is still a fascination with houses of ill repute; they are sprinkled through history…
I loved the pictures you included, Linda…
LikeLike
Thanks, Ruth!
Sex always has and I suspect always will sell. Love it or hate it, the taboos, moralistic judgements, and attempts to hide it between the sheets only serve to make it that much more fascinating. You can ban books, movies, art, and outlaw sex, but without it, we die as a species. (Not such a bad idea.)
I think the images speak a bit more eloquently than I do. 🙂
LikeLike
Since we were/are a port town, there was a red light district here too. Sailors, shore leave, and cash… what a concept. I love that big red house and the fish mural. I’m glad to see the town come to life again.
LikeLike
Sex sells. Especially to sailors and miners!
It’s always nice to see a small town reinvent itself. 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great post – love those colourful buildings. Probably not much fun for the girls working in those brothels – personal hygiene wasn’t very important to the men in the mines.
LikeLike
I often think of that. ghhaaaa. But work was work. There weren’t many options for women at that time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fascinating subjects; restauration and old brothels. Of course Amsterdam’s red light district reigns over the Reeperbahn.
The Amsterdam brothels are situated in a very expensive part of Amsterdam. It is total bedlam during the summer months when the deprived tourists arrive for a couple of hours by huge dominating cruisers. For some it is a toss-up between the Van Gogh museum or a look at the red light district.
LikeLike
Personally, I’d pick the Van Gogh in a heartbeat. But perhaps that’s because I’ve already experienced the Reeperbahn. It’s not worth a second, whereas that museum could lure me back dozens of times.
LikeLike
Oh yeah … all the towns around here had several brothels back in the mining days! Populations of some were larger too. Great photos and story-telling. I laughed out loud at ‘plowing through the mass of people like an ox dragging a Conestoga wagon over Donner Pass’ and the picture it conjured up!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think only a western American would fully appreciate the Conestoga over Donner Pass. 🤣
LikeLike